Incomm Launches ‘Your Gift Choice’ Gift Cards: Redeem For Amazon, Amex, Visa, Best Buy & More

Not content with ChooseYourCard and Zillions gift cards, Incomm has launched another type of multi-store gift card – Your Gift Choice. This one has the potential to be the best multi-store gift card brand out there, but you might have to cross your fingers when buying one.

Side note: the name of this gift card brand is named awfully IMO. It’s awkward sounding as it feels like it either needs another word in its name or some kind of punctuation. Something like ‘Your Gift Of Choice’ or ‘Your Gift: Choice’ would be a little better.

Where Can You Buy ‘Your Gift Choice’ Gift Cards?

Reader Roman brought this to my attention as he noticed that TopCashback is selling them. At the time of publishing this, TopCashback is offering 2.35% cashback on them which is OK, but nothing special. Where it could come in handy is when they run their ‘Spend $15, get $2.50 bonus cashback‘ deals. You can only buy these in $25, $50 and $100 denominations, but buying one during one of those promotions would earn you $0.59 cashback as standard plus the $2.50 bonus cashback for a total of $3.09 – a 12.36% return.

On the Your Gift Choice website, it states that these gift cards can be purchased at Walmart and Sam’s Club online. It has buttons you can click to ‘Visit Walmart.com’ and ‘Visit SamsClub.com’, but neither of those buttons link to those external websites. Instead, they just direct you back to the same page on the Your Gift Choice website. Even when going directly to the Walmart and Sam’s Club websites, I can’t find these cards listed there yet, so that website page seems to be suffering from premature epublication.

How Do You Redeem ‘Your Gift Choice’ Gift Cards?

These gift cards work in much the same way as other multi-store gift cards issued by both Incomm and Blackhawk Network (Zillions, ChooseYourCard, Choice, One4All, Giving Good, etc.), but with their own unique redemption site.

After buying a Your Gift Choice gift card, you have to go to RedeemYourGiftChoice.com. You then enter the card’s value and the gift card number; it doesn’t seem like there’s a PIN. After clicking ‘Next’, you’ll see a list of gift card brands. It initially defaults to a handful of featured cards, so you’ll want to select ‘Show All’ in order to see all eligible brands that you can redeem the Your Gift Choice gift card for.

Depending on the value of the card you bought, you can redeem it for multiple different brands. For example, if you bought a $100 gift card, you could redeem it for four $25 gift cards for four different retailers or restaurants if you like.

Which Brands Can You Redeem ‘Your Gift Choice’ Gift Cards For?

This is where this particular multi-store brand gets a little annoying (beyond its name). When going to both the YourGiftChoice.com and RedeemYourGiftChoice.com websites, you can’t see what brands you can redeem the gift card for. The only way to do that is to buy a gift card and actually redeem it.

So that’s what I did.

The great news is that there’s a huge array of eligible brands, including many high value brands. That includes Amazon, Airbnb, Best Buy, Home Depot, Apple, Disney, Nike, Walmart and more. Even Vanilla Visa and American Express gift cards are available on there (I’ve published a separate post about that here).

I wouldn’t be at all surprised if this ends up like Zillions gift cards where they chop and change eligible retailers. If that’s the case it’ll be annoying because it means you could buy a gift card and find out the retailer(s) you’re interested in are no longer there. However, here’s a complete list of eligible brands as of August 23, 2024.

n.b. This list is what was available to me after buying a Your Gift Choice gift card from TopCashback. Other readers have reported buying one of these cards from another outlet which didn’t include Visa and Amex gift cards. It therefore seems like the redemption options could be different based on where you buy these gift cards from which is frustrating as that gives you even less of an idea as to which gift cards you can exchange them for.

• 1-800-Baskets.com
• 1-800-Flowers.com
• 1-800-Pet Supplies
• Ace Hardware
• Adidas
• Aerie
• Aéropostale
• Airbnb
• Amazon.com
• AMC Theatres
• American Eagle Outfitters
• American Express Business Gift Card
• American Express Business eGift Card
• Amtrak
• Apple Gift Card
• Applebee’s
• ASOS
• Athleta
• Autozone
• BabyGap/GapKids
• Bahama Breeze
• Banana Republic
• Barnes & Noble
• Bass Pro Shops
• Bath & Body Works
• Bed Bath & Beyond
• Belk
• Benihana
• Best Buy Egift Card
• Best Buy
• Black Angus Steakhouse
• Blimpie
• Bloomingdale’s
• Bob Evans
• Bonefish Grill
• Boscov’s
• Bubba Gump Shrimp Co.
• Buffalo Wild Wings
• Burger King
• Burlington
• Cabela’s
• California Pizza Kitchen
• Callaway Golf (minimum $50)
• Carnival Cruise Lines (minimum $100)
• Carrabba’s Italian Grill
• CB2
• Champs Sports
• CharityChoice
• CharityChoice – Boys & Girls Club of America
• CharityChoice – American Cancer Society
• CharityChoice – American Red Cross
• CharityChoice – Wounded Warrior Project
• CharityChoice – World Wildlife Fund
• Chart House
• Cheddar’s Scratch Kitchen
• The Cheesecake Factory
• Chewy
• The Children’s Place
• Chili’s
• Chipotle
• Chuck E Cheese
• Cold Stone Creamery
• Columbia Sportswear
• Cracker Barrel
• Crate & Barrel
• Crutchfield
• CVS
• Dairy Queen
• Darden
• Dave & Busters
• Delta Air Lines (minimum $50)
• Dick’s Sporting Goods
• Disney
• Domino’s
• DoorDash
• DSW
• Dunkin Donuts
• Fairmont Hotels & Resorts
• Famous Dave’s
• Fanatics
• Fandango
• Fleming’s
• Foot Locker
• Fragrancenet.com
• Gambit
• GameStop
• Gap
• Gap Options
• Global Hotel Card ($25 & $50 only)
• Go Play Golf
• Google Play
• Groupon
• Grubhub
• Guitar Center
• H&M
• Harley-Davidson
• Harry & David
• Home Depot
• HomeGoods
• Hotels.com
• Hulu
• iFLY
• IHOP
• Instacart
• JCPenney
• Jersey Mike’s
• Jiffy Lube
• JOANN Stores
• Kids Foot Locker
• Kohl’s
• Krispy Kreme
• L.L.Bean
• Lady Foot Locker
• Landry’s
• Lands’ End
• Lane Bryant
• Legal Seafoods
• Lobster Gram
• Logan’s Roadhouse
• Longhorn Steakhouse
• Lowe’s
• lululemon
• Lyft
• Macy’s
• Macy’s
• Maggiano’s
• Marshalls
• McCormick & Schmick’s
• McDonald’s
• Meijer
• Michael’s
• Mitchell’s Fish Market
• Mix It Up
• Morton’s The Steakhouse
• NASCAR.com
• NFLShop.com
• Nike
• Ninety Nine Restaurants
• Nintendo eShop
• Nordstrom
• Nordstrom Rack
• O’Charley’s
• Oceanaire Seafood Room
• Old Navy
• Olive Garden
• Omaha Steaks
• On The Border
• Outback Steakhouse
• Panera Bread
• Papa John’s
• Peet’s Coffee & Tea
• Petco
• P.F. Chang’s
• PinkBerry
• Pottery Barn
• Princess Cruise Lines eGift Card
• Princess Cruise Lines (minimum $50)
• Rainforest Café
• Red Lobster
• Red Robin
• Regal Cinemas
• REI
• Roblox
• Royal Caribbean (minimum $50)
• Ruby Tuesday
• Ruth’s Chris Steak House
• Saks Fifth Avenue
• Saltgrass Steak House
• Sam’s Club
• Seasons 52
• Sephora
• Shutterfly
• SiriusXM
• Skechers
• Sling TV
• Sonic
• PlayStation Store
• Southwest Airlines
• Speedy Cash
• Spotify
• Staples
• Staples eGift Card
• Starbucks
• Stitch Fix
• StubHub
• Subway
• Sunglass Hut
• Vanilla Visa Gift Card Sutton
• Vanilla eGift Visa Virtual Account
• T.J. Maxx
• Taco Bell
• Target
• Texas Roadhouse
• TGI Fridays
• The Container Store
• The Popcorn Factory
• The Vitamin Shoppe
• Tommy Bahama
• Topgolf
• Total Wine & More
• TripGift
• Uber
• Uber Eats
• Ulta Beauty
• Under Armour
• UNO Pizzeria & Grill
• Vudu
• Walmart
• Wayfair
• west elm
• White House Black Market
• Williams-Sonoma
• Xbox Gift Card
• Yard House
• Zappos.com

As you can see, there are ~200 eligible brands that can be redeemed for with Your Gift Choice gift cards. If you can obtain these at a discount or in a rewarding way, that could make these very interesting indeed.